Called gherkins' value $400 answer envoy round Jeopardy! Show_number 5831 category SAME TITLE DIFFERENT SONG air_date 2008-06-25 question 'The Shirelles said \Tonight you're mine completely\ but weren't sold' value $400 answer Cinnabon round Double Jeopardy! Show_number 3838 category THE 2011 EMMYS air_date 2009-12-14.